If I were to trace my timeline of Amanda Palmer-fandom, it is probably this release that turned me in to superfan. Previous releases were good, but I experienced them after their release, Evelyn Evelyn was one I pre-ordered (ordering a package with many goodies). The release itself is HILARIOUS, touching, beautiful, and… old-timey. The narrative that is woven into the songs themselves is part storytelling and part stand-up comedy, while the songs are catchy as hell.
Favorite Track: Elephant Elephant
Second Favorite: Chicken Man